top of page

A Behaviorist's Take on Automatic Litter Boxes: Are They Really Worth It?

felidaebehavior
4 minutes ago
5 min read

We live in a world where just about everything can be made smarter. Smart homes, smart cars, smart watches, and even smart rings are designed to make our daily lives easier and help streamline our routines.


Naturally, the smart-home revolution has extended to our pets, too. These days, you can buy smart feeders, automatic cat flaps, toys, and even self-cleaning litter boxes.


Automatic litter boxes promise to take one of the less enjoyable parts of cat ownership off your hands. No more daily scooping! Just let the machine do the work and empty the waste reservoir every so often. Sounds great, right?


But before you spend hundreds of dollars on one, let's look at things from your cat's perspective.


The Advantages: Mostly for Us Humans


There's no denying that automatic litter boxes offer some conveniences for their owners.


The biggest selling point is obvious: less scooping. Instead of manually cleaning the litter

Person lifts a white litter bag from a gray Neakasa self-cleaning litter box in a cozy living room.

box once or twice a day, the machine does it for you. Depending on the model, waste is collected in a reservoir that only needs to be emptied periodically.


For busy households, this can sound like a wonderful solution. Some models also offer features such as usage tracking, notifications, and monitoring that can provide information about your cat's litter box habits.


But here's the important question: Just because something makes our lives easier, does that mean it makes life better for our cats?


The Disadvantages: What Does Your Cat Think?


Cats can be particular about their bathroom habits, and for good reason. They need a place where they feel comfortable, safe, and able to eliminate without unnecessary stress. Unfortunately, some of the features that make automatic litter boxes appealing to humans can make them less appealing to cats.


Here are some potential drawbacks worth considering.


1. Strange noises

Automatic litter boxes make noise. Some are relatively quiet, while others can be surprisingly loud when the cleaning cycle begins.


Imagine being in the bathroom and suddenly hearing a machine whirring, grinding, or

moving nearby. You might not think much of it, but for a cat who is sensitive to unfamiliar sounds, it could be startling.


If a cat has an unpleasant experience while using the box, they may begin to associate the box with something frightening.


2. The box moves on its own

In addition to making noise, these boxes move. Depending on the design, parts of the unit rotate, rake, or shift during the cleaning cycle.


Cats generally prefer predictable environments. Having their bathroom suddenly move or change around them isn't necessarily going to be a welcome experience.


3. Mechanical problems can leave your cat without a usable litter box

This is something I experienced firsthand when I worked as a cat sitter. I would occasionally arrive at a client's home to find that the automatic litter box had become stuck in the middle of its cleaning cycle.


The result? The cat couldn't use it and had to find an alternative place to go.


When a traditional litter box gets dirty, a cat can still get into it. With an automatic box, a mechanical failure can make the entire unit unusable until someone notices and fixes the problem.


And if you're away from home for the day or traveling, your cat may be left without an appropriate place to eliminate.


4. They're not always easy to clean

One of the selling points of an automatic litter box is that you don't have to scoop. But that doesn't mean you never have to clean it.


The interior components, crevices, and moving parts can collect litter dust, urine residue, and other debris. Depending on the design, getting into all those areas to clean them properly can be difficult.


Over time, a buildup of waste can create unpleasant odors and an unhygienic environment. Cats have a much better sense of smell than we do, so a box that seems clean enough to us may not be particularly appealing to them.


5. Size matters!

This is one of my biggest concerns with many automatic litter boxes.


Cats need enough room to comfortably enter, turn around, dig, eliminate, and cover their waste. Some automatic models simply don't provide enough interior space, particularly for larger cats.


Older cats may also have difficulty maneuvering inside a confined space, especially if they have arthritis or other mobility limitations.


A litter box shouldn't require your cat to squeeze, twist, or contort their body just to use it. They need room to move comfortably and assume their preferred elimination posture.


6. Getting into the box shouldn't be a workout

Many automatic litter boxes have elevated entrances or require cats to climb into the unit.

Think about it: When you need to use the bathroom, do you want to climb up into a small enclosed space before you can go?

Ginger cat stands beside a gray automatic litter box in a bright room, looking at the camera.

Probably not!


For kittens, senior cats, and cats with mobility issues, climbing into an elevated litter box can be particularly challenging. Even healthy adult cats may simply prefer an easier option.

A litter box should be easy to access, not another obstacle your cat has to navigate.


Just Because Your Cat Uses It Doesn't Mean They Love It

Now, I'm not suggesting that every cat will refuse to use an automatic litter box. Plenty of cats use them without any obvious problems.


But there's an important distinction between a cat being willing to use something and that thing actually meeting their needs.


In my behavior consulting practice, I work with many cats who are experiencing litter box problems. In some cases, the underlying issue isn't complicated at all. The litter box itself is the problem.


The box may be too small, difficult to access, uncomfortable, or simply not a place where the cat wants to eliminate.


I've seen cases where replacing an unsuitable litter box with a larger, more accessible option is all it takes to resolve the problem.


It's a good reminder that sometimes the solution isn't another expensive gadget, a new type of litter, or a complicated behavior modification plan. Sometimes, it's just giving the cat a better bathroom.


My Recommendation: Save Your Money!

If you're considering spending several hundred dollars on an automatic litter box, my advice is to think twice.

Gray cat sits in a beige litter box filled with litter, facing away in a cozy indoor scene.

Instead, consider buying a large plastic storage bin and converting it into a litter box. You can cut an opening in the side to create an easy-access entrance, making it suitable for cats

of different sizes and mobility levels.


Look for a bin that provides plenty of room for your cat to move around comfortably. You don't need anything fancy, and you certainly don't need an electronic device to make it work.


Yes, you'll have to scoop it. I recommend scooping at least twice a day, but I promise it will only takes a couple of minutes once it becomes part of your routine.


You'll save yourself hundreds of dollars, your cat will have a spacious and accessible bathroom, and you won't have to worry about a machine malfunctioning and leaving your cat without a usable litter box.


At the end of the day, the best litter box isn't necessarily the one with the most technology. It's the one that allows your cat to comfortably and confidently do what they need to do.

And that's what matters most!

bottom of page